Looking for song since 2010.

This song is my white whale. Once I find this song I will be happy and probably get my life together.

So this song came out between 2002-2010. Maybe 11 if I somehow estimated wrong lol. But the song had the sound of the early 2000s like taking back Sunday.

In fact I always thought it was them. But I remember when I looked them up around 2010 their online info said it was one album band that disbanded and maybe from the east coast.

The only lyrics I remember are from the intro and are not 100% correct:

“I caught you red handed at the scene or the crime”

The intro had that early 2000s post hardcore strum like cute without the E and then continues fast strumming. But it was only one fast clean strum and then into fast paced rhythm.

I don’t recall any screaming vocals but maybe.

All I know is that I would be super grateful to find this one song from this band.

Edit: you guys and girls are awesome for trying to help me. I haven’t found the song yet but I’m going to search this weekend and give you guys and update if you want.